It's never happened before in Daytime Emmy history: two soaps tied for the biggest honor of the night, Outstanding Drama Series. Even presenter Rachel Ray seemed surprised when she opened the envelope and found two pieces of paper inside.
"It belongs to our fans who have been there for us," Wheeler said, prompting what would be the most stunning declaration in Daytime Emmy history.
"Seven people will have the opportunity to have this very Emmy come visit them in their home," Wheeler said pointing to the golden statuette clutched tightly in her hands.
Wheeler urged fans to visit the show's web site, "FindYourLight.net," devoted to making a difference and volunteering. Details of how and when fans can enter to win a chance to spend some time with the lovely Emmy will be made available at a later time.
This marked only the third time that Guiding Light was honored as Outstanding Drama Series. Its last win came 25 years ago, in 1982. Its other win was in 1980.
The other top soap winner was The Young and the Restless, notching its sixth win in 28 nominations. For 22 consecutive years, The Young and the Restless has found its name in the Outstanding Drama Series field.
"I'm just so honored to be here," said Y&R's executive producer and head writer Lynn Latham. "It's just a gift. There are so many people involved and so many people to thank. I mean this sincerely I have never worked with a cast of this caliber."
"It was a marvelous show when I came on," Latham stated. "We have tried to speed up the pace of the show."
Latham also noted that the show has experimented with new music and new filming techniques.
When asked how it felt to share the top honors of the night, Latham replied simply, "It's marvelous. Honestly."
Guiding Light's Wheeler was just as diplomatic. "I wish we could give [an Emmy] to everybody!"